哈利波特吧 关注:952,726贴子:14,769,804

【哈学讨论】唱唱正调第十四期——卢修斯·马尔福

只看楼主收藏回复

未见END请勿插楼,插楼者嫁Y受鱼老板,新房面壁十天


1楼2014-06-01 18:59回复
    《哈利波特与密室》
    第18章 多比的报偿
     哈利站起身,向门口走去。他刚握住门把手,门突然被大力撞开,嘭地弹在后面的墙上。
      卢修斯·马尔福站在那里,神情怒不可遏。那战战兢兢被他夹在他胳膊底下的,正是多比,身上到处都缠着绷带。
      “晚上好,卢修斯。”邓布利多和颜悦色地说。
      马尔福一头冲进房间,差点把哈利撞了个跟头。多比惊慌失措地跟在后面,弯腰曲背,盯着主人长袍背后的接缝,脸上挂着绝望无助的恐惧。
      “好啊!”卢修斯·马尔福冷冰冰的眼睛盯住邓布利多,说道,“你回来了。董事会暂停了你的职务,可是你仍然自作主张地回到了霍格沃茨。”
      “噢,是这样的,卢修斯,”邓布利多平静地微笑着,说道,“今天,另外的十一位董事都和我取得了联系。说句实话,当时猫头鹰接二连三地飞来,就好像下了一场冰雹。他们听说亚瑟·韦斯莱的女儿被害死了,都希望我立刻赶到这里。他们似乎认为,弄了半天,还是我最适合担任这份工作。他们还告诉了我一些奇怪的故事。他们有些人似乎认为,你曾经威胁说,如果他们不同意暂停我的职务。你就要诅咒他们的家人。”
      马尔福先生的脸比平时更加苍白了,但他的眼睛里仍然喷着怒火。
      “那么——你有没有阻止那些攻击事件呢?”他讥讽地问,“你有没有抓住凶手呢?”
      “我们抓住了。”邓布利多微笑着回答他。
      “噢?”马尔福先生厉声地问,“是谁?”
      “还是上次的那个人,卢修斯,”邓布利多说,“不过,伏地魔这次是通过另一个人活动的。凭借他的日记。”
      他举起那个中间贯穿着一个大洞的小黑本子,密切地注视着马尔福先生的反应。而哈利却望着多比。
      那个家养小精灵的行为非常古怪。他那两只灯泡大的眼睛富有深意地盯着哈利,一边不停地指指那本日记,又指指马尔福先生,然后狠狠地用拳头敲打。自己的脑袋。
      “原来是这样……”马尔福先生慢慢地对邓布利多说。
      “一个巧妙的计划,”邓布利多语调平和地说,仍然逼视着马尔福先生的眼睛,“如果这位哈利——”——马尔福先生用严厉的目光飞快地瞪了哈利一下——“和他的朋友罗恩没有发现这本日记。哎呀——金妮,韦斯莱可能就要背黑锅了。谁也没有办法证明她不是按自己的意志行动的……”
      马尔福一言不发,他的脸突然像是罩上了一层假面具。
      “想象一下吧,”邓布利多继续说,“那样会出现什么情况……韦斯莱一家是最有名望的纯血统巫师家族之一。想象一下吧,如果人们发现亚瑟·韦斯莱的亲生女儿在攻击和谋害麻瓜出身的人,这对韦斯莱和他的麻瓜保护法会产生什么影响。幸好这本日记被发现了,里德尔的记忆也从上面被抹消了。不然的话,谁知道会造成什么后果呢……”
      马尔福先生强追自己开口说话了。
      “真是万幸。”他很不自然地说。
      缩在他身后的多比,仍然很古怪地先指指那本日记,又指指卢修斯·马尔福,随即拼命地捶打自己的脑袋。哈利突然明白了。他朝多比点了点头,于是多比退缩到墙角,又狠狠地揪着自己的耳朵作为惩罚。“你不想知道金妮是怎么得到这本日记的吗,马尔福先生?”哈利说。卢修斯·马尔福朝他转过身来。“我凭什么知道那个愚蠢的小姑娘是怎么得到它的?”他说。“因为是你给她的,”哈利说,“在丽痕书店,你捡起她的变形课本,偷偷地把日记本塞在里面,是不是?”
      他看见马尔福苍白的双手攥成了拳头,随即又松开了。
      “有证据吗?"他嘶哑着声音说。
      “哦,谁也没有办法提供证据了,”邓布利多笑眯眯地看着哈利,说道,“现在里德尔已经从本子里消失了。另外,卢修斯,我要给你一句忠告,不要再散发伏地魔学生时代的旧东西了。如果又有这些东西落到无辜者的手里,至少亚瑟·韦斯莱就肯定能查明它们是从你那儿出来的……”
      卢修斯·马尔福又呆立了片刻,哈利清清楚楚地看见他的右手抽动了一下,似乎想去掏他的魔杖。然而他克制住了自己,转身对他的家养小精灵说:“我们走了,多比!”
      他拧开了门,家养小精灵慌忙跑了过来,马尔福先生一脚把他踢出门去。他们可以听见多比痛苦的尖叫声沿着走廊一路传来。哈利站在那里,苦苦地思索了片刻。然后,他有了主意。
      “邓布利多教授,”他匆匆忙忙地说,“请问,我能把这本日记还给马尔福先生吗?”“当然可以,哈利,”邓布利多平静地说,“不过可得快点儿。别忘了还有宴会呢。”
    哈利一把抓过日记本,冲出了办公室。他听见多比痛苦的惨叫声绕过拐角,越来越远了。哈利一边心里怀疑这个计划能不能行得通,一边飞快地脱掉一只鞋,扯下黏糊糊的臭袜子,把日记本塞了进去。然后,他沿着黑暗的走廊飞奔。
      就在那两个人正要下楼梯时,他追上了他们。
      “马尔福先生,”他喘着气说,一个踉跄,刹住脚步,“我有一样东西要给你。”
      他把那只臭烘烘的袜子硬塞进卢修斯·马尔福手里。
      “这是什——”马尔福先生扯掉日记本上的袜子,扔到一边,怒气冲冲地看了看被毁坏的日记本,又看了看哈利。“哈利·波特,总有一天,你会遭到和你父母同样的下场,”他轻声说,“他们当年就是爱管闲事的傻瓜。”
      他转身要走。
      “快来,多比。听见没有,快点儿!”
      可是多比没有动弹。他高高举起哈利的那只黏糊糊的臭袜子,激动地看着它,就好像那是一件无价之宝。
      “主人给了多比一只袜子,”家养小精灵惊讶地说,“主人把袜子给了多比。”
      “什么?”马尔福先生恼火地说,“你说什么?”
      “多比得到了一只袜子,”多比不敢相信地说。“是主人扔的,多比接住了,多比——多比自由了。”
      卢修斯·马尔福呆呆地站在那里,瞪着家养小精灵。然后他突然向哈利扑去。
      “你害得我失去了我的家仆,小子!”
      可是多比喊道:“不许你伤害哈利·波特!”
      只听梆的一声巨响,马尔福先生向后倒去。他跌跌撞撞、一步三级地冲下楼梯,最后乱糟糟地瘫倒在下面的平台上。他挣扎着站起来,脸色铁青,抽出了魔杖,可是多比举起了一只修长的、很有威力的手指。
      “你可以走了,”他指着下面的马尔福先生,凶狠地说,“你永远不许碰哈利·波特。你现在可以走了。”
    卢修斯·马尔福没有别的办法。他怒气冲冲地瞪了他们俩最后一眼,用斗篷裹住身体,匆匆地消失了。


    3楼2014-06-01 19:03
    回复
      英文
      《HARRY POTTER AND THE CHAMBEROF SECRETS 》
      Chapter18 Dobby's reward
      Harry got up andcrossed to the door. He had just reached for the
      handle, however,when the door burst open so violently that it bounced
      back off thewall.
      Lucius Malfoystood there, fury in his face. And cowering behind his legs, heavily wrapped inbandages, was Dobby.
      "Goodevening, Lucius," said Dumbledore pleasantly.
      Mr. Malfoyalmost knocked Harry over as he swept into the room. Dobby went scurrying in after him, crouchingat the hem of his cloak, a look ofabject terror on his face. The elf wascarrying a stained rag with which he was attempting to finish cleaning Mr. Malfoys shoes. ApparentlyMr. Malfoy had set out in a great hurry,for not only were his shoes half-polished, but his usually sleek hair was disheveled. Ignoringthe elf bobbing apologetically aroundhis ankles, he fixed his cold eyes upon Dumbledore.
      "So!"he said "You've come back. The governors suspended you, but you still saw fit to return toHogwarts."
      "Well, you see, Lucius," saidDumbledore, smiling serenely, "the othereleven governors contacted me today. It was something like being caught in ahailstorm of owls, to tell the truth. They'd heard that Arthur Weasleysdaughter had been killed and wanted me back here at once. They seemed to think I was the bestman for the job after all. Very strange tales they told me, too .... Several ofthem seemed to think that you had threatened to curse their families if theydidn't agree to suspend me in the first place."
      Mr. Malfoy wenteven paler than usual, but his eyes were still slits of fury.
      "So -- haveyou stopped the attacks yet?" he sneered. "Have you caught the culprit?"
      "Wehave," said Dumbledore, with a smile.
      "Well?"saidMr. Malfoy sharply. "Who is it?"
      "The sameperson as last time, Lucius," said Dumbledore. "But this time, LordVoldemort was acting through somebody else. By means of this diary."
      He held up thesmall black book with the large hole through the center, watching Mr. Malfoy closely. Harry,however, was watching Dobby.
      The elf wasdoing something very odd. His great eyes fixed meaningfully on Harry, he keptpointing at the diary, then at Mr. Malfoy, and then hitting himself hard on thehead with his fist.
      "I see. . ." said Mr. Malfoy slowly to Dumbledore.
      "A cleverplan," said Dumbledore in a level voice, still staring Mr. Malfoy straightin the eye. "Because if Harry here" --Mr. Malfoy shot Harry a swift,sharp look -- "and his friend Ron hadn't discovered this book, why -- GinnyWeasley might have taken all the blame. No one would ever have been able toprove she hadn't acted of her own free will ......
      Mr. Malfoy saidnothing. His face was suddenly masklike.
      "Andimagine," Dumbledore went on, "what might have happened then .... TheWeasleys are one of our most prominent pure-blood families. Imagine the effecton Arthur Weasley and his Muggle Protection Act, if his own daughter wasdiscovered attacking and - killing Muggle-borns .... Very fortunate the diarywas discovered, and Riddle's memories wiped from it. "Who knows what the consequencesmight have been otherwise ......
      Mr. Malfoyforced himself to speak.
      "Veryfortunate," he said stiffly.
      And still,behind his back, Dobby was pointing, first to the diary, then to Lucius Malfoy, then punching himselfin the head. And Harry suddenlyunderstood. He nodded at Dobby, and Dobby backed into a corner, now twisting his ears in punishment. "Don't you want to know how Ginny gothold of that diary, Mr. Malfoy?" said Harry. Lucius Malfoy rounded on him. "How should I know how the stupid littlegirl got hold of it?" he said. "Becauseyou gave it to her," said Harry. "In Flourish and Blotts. You picked up her old Transfiguration bookand slipped the diary inside it, didn'tyou?"
      He saw Mr.Malfoy's white hands clench and unclench.
      "Proveit," he hissed.
      "Oh, no onewill be able to do that," said Dumbledore, smiling at Harry. "Not now that Riddle has vanishedfrom the book. On the other hand, I would advise you, Lucius, not to go givingout any more of Lord Voldemort's oldschool things. If any more of them find theirway into innocent hands, I think Arthur Weasley, for one, will make sure they are traced back to you......
      Lucius Malfoystood for a moment, and Harry distinctly saw his right hand twitch as though he was longing to reachfor his wand. Instead, he turned to hishouse-elf
      "We'regoing, Dobby!"
      He wrenched openthe door and as the elf came hurrying up to him, he kicked him right through it. They couldhear Dobby squealing with pain all theway along the corridor. Harry stood for a moment, thinking hard. Then it came to him -
      "ProfessorDumbledore," he said hurriedly. "Can I give that diary back to Mr. Malfoy, please?"
      "Certainly,Harry," said Dumbledore calmly. "But hurry. The feast, remember ......
      Harry grabbedthe diary and dashed out of the office. He could hear Dobby's squeals of pain receding around thecorner. Quickly, wondering if this plancould possibly work, Harry took off one of his shoes, pulled off his slimy, filthy sock, and stuffed the diary intoit. Then he ran down the darkcorridor.
      He caught upwith them at the top of the stairs.
      "Mr.Malfoy," he gasped, skidding to a halt, "I've got something for you --"
      And he forced thesmelly sock into Lucius Malfoy's hand.
      ")What the--?"
      Mr. Malfoyripped the sock off the diary, threw it aside, then looked furiously from the ruined book to Harry. You'll meet the same sticky end as yourparents one of these days,
      HarryPotter," he said softly. "They were meddlesome fools, too.
      He turned togo.
      "Come,Dobby. I said, come."
      But Dobby didn'tmove. He was holding up Harry's disgusting, slimy sock, and looking at it as though it were apriceless treasure.
      "Master hasgiven a sock," said the elf in wonderment. "Master gave it to Dobby."
      "What'sthat?" spat Mr. Malfoy. "What did you say?"
      "Got asock," said Dobby in disbelief. "Master threw it, and Dobby caught it, and Dobby -- Dobby is free."
      Lucius Malfoystood frozen, staring at the elf Then he lunged at Harry.
      "You'velost me my servant, boy!"
      But Dobbyshouted, "You shall not harm Harry Potter!"
      There was a loudbang, and Mr. Malfoy was thrown backward. He crashed down the stairs, three at a time, landing in a crumpledheap on the landing below. He got up,his face livid, and pulled out his wand, but Dobby raised a long, threateningfinger.
      "You shallgo now," he said fiercely, pointing down at Mr. Malfoy. "You shall not touch Harry Potter. Youshall go now."
      Lucius Malfoyhad no choice. With a last, incensed stare at the pair of them, he swung his cloak around him andhurried out of sight.


      4楼2014-06-01 19:05
      回复
        ===========================END==========================
        欢迎大家各抒己见,请和谐讨论,严禁争吵,另,【本楼禁水】,水贴刷经验者封号无误。


        本楼含有高级字体5楼2014-06-01 19:06
        回复
          卢修斯·马尔福,在他身上体现的最明显的两点是明哲保身和利己主义。
          卢修斯,作为巫师当中的纯血,他在骨子里是看不起麻瓜以及麻瓜出身的巫师的,这可以从德拉科马尔福的言谈看出(有其父必有其子)。因此他应当是伏地魔的忠实支持者之一。然而,在伏地魔垮台后,卢修斯及其家人却是第一批倒向魔法部的,声称自己被夺魂咒控制而身不由己,相当于叛离了食死徒。当黑魔标记再度亮起时,卢修斯和纳西莎,却又出现在伏地魔的复活之处,证明他们又重回食死徒行列。而在最后一战的时候,纳西莎一听说德拉科还在城堡,甚至愿意瞒过伏地魔通过食死徒占领军进入城堡寻找德拉科,作为她丈夫的卢修斯,跟她做法几乎一致:在大厅战斗白热化时,卢修斯和纳西莎一起到处找德拉科,俨然不加入战斗。传说中的墙头草。
          与卢修斯相对比,贝姨就硬气得多了。贝姨在伏地魔垮台消失之后仍然公开宣称效忠于伏地魔并因此而被抓捕,越狱后东躲西藏。而在伏地魔复活当夜,贝姨也出现在了坟地,霍格沃茨的最后一战,贝姨在与韦斯莱夫人的对决中战死。相比而言,贝姨虽然支持的是所谓“恶势力”一方,但她对伏地魔的忠诚和她不屈(或者叫死性不改?)的精神也比见风使舵的卢修斯更让人感慨。
          而利己主义既体现在卢修斯为保全性命见风使舵的行为,也在引文中有所体现。引文中提到,他为了设计陷害韦斯莱先生从而达到阻止《麻瓜保护法》出台的目的,甚至不惜把他曾经效忠的主人让他保存的重要物品:魂器之一的里德尔日记,偷偷塞给了金妮。古人讲究忠义,卢修斯这一举动,既不忠于伏地魔,这一卑劣手段又摆不上台面,可谓不义。仅仅是为了一己私利却表现出了他不忠不义的一面。但是贝姨至少是忠字当头。这就是我不喜欢卢修斯却可怜贝姨悲剧结局的原因。
          相比与其他食死徒,卢修斯有一个巨大的家业,可能他不能像别人那样死忠于伏地魔并表露在外。他的见风使舵明哲保身,可能是想保全家业保全家人而不仅是顾及个人安危。而他对德拉科的父爱体现了在食死徒行列中为数不多的人性(贝姨可是亲手杀了自己的弟弟)。因此他的明哲保身利己主义,虽然为人不齿,但是也应该有他心中的苦衷。
          综上所述,我认为卢修斯是一个复杂的人,并不能单纯以某一个标签来定义。


          IP属地:上海10楼2014-06-01 20:00
          收起回复
            卢修斯,高贵的纯血统,明哲保身,一切为了家族。


            来自Android客户端11楼2014-06-01 20:45
            回复
              恩哼,关于卢修斯,其实大家都已经原谅他了,他的所作所为都是为了马尔福。


              来自手机贴吧12楼2014-06-01 21:10
              回复
                卢修斯啊。。。我对于他身上能赞成的品质只有他对家人的爱吧。。。虽然在这方面我觉得书中他体现相比纳西莎也黯然失色。
                不过我不明白为什么有人会只因为这点就能对这个角色进行洗白,当然估计他身上贵族的属性太招luli了吧?还有所谓的同人二设“铂金贵族”,这点我能吐槽下妹子们都是色盲么,还有马尔福家的贵族是麻瓜授予的啊,如果他敢用所谓“贵族”的身份来招摇,在纯血家族圈里他首先混不下去吧
                不过我觉得从书中的描写,即使卢修斯一副高人一等的傲慢样子,作为一个人来说,真心格调太低。
                先说对伏地魔吧,显然没有啥忠心可言,这段描写就很明白,伏地魔失势后自己靠狡辩躲过一劫过着体面的生活也就罢了,但为了一己之私(为了陷害一个地位名望远不如自己的政敌,下手的对象还是人家无辜的小女儿),居然还敢动伏地魔让他保管的重要物品。这no zuo no die啊!
                而且之后在失了伏地魔的欢心之后,他表现真的很怂,还不如纳西莎一个女子。纳西莎还敢于在伏地魔让德拉科被指派去杀邓布利多后不顾伏地魔的禁令去找斯内普,也敢在最后哈利诈死时骗伏地魔。这两点作为“保护家人”这个萌点的确很加分。但是卢修斯么,说实话真的没啥特出彩的表现。
                然后再看这段描写吧,可以看到相比邓布利多,卢修斯才更会玩政治手腕。威逼利诱,把邓布利多赶出了霍格沃兹。如果不是局势动乱严峻,邓布利多只靠政治力量和卢修斯硬拼,没准还真拼不过,毕竟邓布利多其实空有名望没有实权。当然这俩人在战略层面就没啥好比的了,根本不是一个级别的。。。
                还有最后被哈利设计解放了多比之后,在校长室的走廊里气急败坏想对哈利这个二年级的学生念咒也就罢了(话说电影里这里卢修斯念的还是索命咒,不过既然电影不是原著,就不讨论了),在多比动手干预并威胁后,就真的掉头走掉了。。。这欺软怕硬不要太明显啊喂!
                说了这些,如果有luli看到估计要掐我了吧?不过我想说人家罗琳就是这么设计这个角色的,马尔福名字的含义就是背信弃义。
                我见过最搞的就是有luli为了给马尔福洗白而黑罗琳的,号称人家仇富。这种言论我还看到不止一次,真是对这种逻辑叹为观止。合算人家仇富还把自己主角给设计成富二代了。而且罗琳仇富是要仇视她自己么,有几个人比她还富,虽然是第一部发表之后才富起来的,后面几部罗琳也没转而把卢修斯描写的形象好点啊?而且人家好歹创作了这个角色让luli YY,结果luli YY完一看原著描写的不合自己心意就要黑作者,这种跟“强黄瓜还要拍黄瓜”的行为有啥差异?


                13楼2014-06-01 21:19
                收起回复
                  为了家族的荣誉,为了纯血,为了名与利!


                  来自iPhone客户端14楼2014-06-01 21:33
                  收起回复
                    好吧,我认为卢修斯这人真是蛮坏,我在电影里看见他说了阿瓦达然后多比就送了他一道蓝光。蛮坏。


                    IP属地:浙江来自iPad15楼2014-06-01 21:42
                    收起回复
                      应该说卢修斯这个人的目的最为简单、明确,就是保全自己及自己的地位、家人、家产,头脑也比较聪明(至少能在部里爬到那么高的位置),借亚瑟的一句原话:这个卢修斯,真是神通广大啊。不管怎么说,这个人的政治嗅觉是很敏感的,典型的黑白通吃,背信弃义。在第2部(应该是,就是哈利用飞路粉走错路那回)里,大家可以看到他劝德拉科不要对哈利表现出公开的反感,很典型的墙头草,哪边形势好就向那边靠。但通过他对儿子的爱,也可以发现,他应该算是Death Eaters里最人性化的了(除斯内普)。同时我们要注意,对于伏地魔,他在本章中的行为已经激怒了他;而对于邓布利多,卢修斯只是他与伏地魔下的这盘大棋中的一枚无足轻重的、也值得可怜的小棋子。


                      IP属地:北京18楼2014-06-01 22:27
                      收起回复
                        卢修斯一直以自己是纯血统巫师而感到很骄傲和自豪。从他第一次出场就能感觉到这一点,在他儿子身上也有所体现。在前六本书,或五本书,卢修斯一直是以这种态度对待哈利以及那些抵抗黑魔王或不是纯血统巫师的人。但到了最后一本书的时候,读者可以明显感觉到,卢修斯以及马尔福家族开始走下坡路了。先是卢修斯没了魔杖,到后来在霍格沃兹的尖叫棚屋里。最后带着一家人逃跑。最后他的样子是多落魄。。不过这也是他应该受到的惩罚。


                        来自Android客户端19楼2014-06-02 00:08
                        回复
                          从第一段中,卢修斯把门大力撞开,能够看出他并不是一个有礼貌的人。大多数人认为他属于贵族,绅士、有教养,可魔法界是 没有贵族的,他只不过是有钱罢 了,而且不懂得礼仪、尊敬。
                          第二段中说到多比缠满绷带,而 且被夹在胳膊下,足以说明他对 待家养小精灵的态度:粗暴。第
                          三段多比的表情也可以看出卢修
                          斯平时是怎么对待他的。从邓布
                          利多的那段话中也能读出卢修斯
                          的人格【是这个词吧我语言表达
                          能力不好】仗势欺人,以权谋
                          私。以及被揭露后的恐慌和愤
                          怒。
                          “想象一下…………卢修斯不自然的
                          回答”他为什么会不自然呢?因
                          为,他的计谋没有得逞,还有一
                          点,邓布利多说韦斯莱家族是最
                          有名望的纯血统家族之一。卢修
                          斯瞧不起韦斯莱家,不会承认他
                          是最有名望的家族。
                          “马尔福苍白的拳头紧握着,随即又松开了”他一开始想动粗,又明白了是自己理亏在先,在动粗更亏,所以松开了拳头,总之,明哲保身,也挺能忍。
                          以上为个人分析,不喜勿喷。
                          另,未完,爪机太麻烦,用电脑再接着发


                          来自手机贴吧20楼2014-06-02 00:45
                          收起回复
                            卢修斯不是一个忠诚的人,不是一个优秀的食死徒,可他至少有爱。他是一个合格的丈夫和父亲。虽然他很阿臾逢迎,可他至少敢为自己的儿子向伏地魔求情。


                            IP属地:河南来自iPad21楼2014-06-02 06:20
                            回复
                              卢修斯和德拉科挺像的,都以为自己血统高贵,可以为所欲为,像只骄傲的白孔雀,却也总在关键时刻掉链子,德拉科是怯懦,卢修斯却是为了这个家,他向往权利追求力量成为食死徒,却没有像贝拉那样忠心奋不顾身,因为他一切还是为了纳西莎和德拉科


                              IP属地:浙江来自Android客户端22楼2014-06-02 08:01
                              收起回复